“I know that I have this depression and that it’s in my family. Every family has their stuff but, for me, I just don’t feel strong enough to see that in a child.” – Sarah Silverman, Stand-Up Comedian
According to a Time Healthland article, the stand-up comedian Sarah Silverman has made it clear that she has no intent of having any children, specifically because of the possibile hereditary nature of her depression.
http://healthland.time.com/2012/06/05/should-depressed-people-avoid-having-children/
In the media and on the Internet, this has inspired debate surrounding the question of whether or not individuals with depression should be worried about passing on the condition to their children, and therefore refrain from having kids.
If you think about it, this could be true of any genetic condition. There are plenty of life threatening conditions that can be passed on from parent to child, does that mean that none of those individuals should have children? What about people with high cholesterol, should they not have kids in order to avoid passing on a condition that could result in heart disease? What about people that just aren’t very pretty or smart? Should they avoid having children that will have to suffer the societal challenges that result from their conditions?
At a certain point, a case can be made for no one having any children. Which would not make for a very sustainable human race.
The author of the article notes: “What the commenters didn’t mention is that the same genes that can cause depression may also encourage the sensitivity and sensibility that gives Silverman her creative talent. Indeed, some research suggests that the same exact genetics that might lead to depression can also lead to mental superhealth, depending on whether a person endured high stress in early childhood or had a calmer, more nurturing environment.”
And hasn’t this been found true throughout time? Often creative geniuses have managed challenges to their mental health, and it provided fuel for their art. And one does not even have to achieve that level of celebrity for their depression to have a unique impact on society. People who are depressed bring a different viewpoint as a result of their condition. They may critique certain elements of society, and call them into question. This is a powerful ability: to see the norms of society, and possibilities outside of them. The main point is, depression can provide individuals with useful qualities.
Still, Sarah Silverman makes an excellent point. Because watching a child struggle with a mental health condition is undoubtedly heart wrenching. And every parent with a mental health condition might face that possibility. Then again, so might every parent in the world. Or their child might face other unforeseen difficulties. And that will always be a struggle. Every individual makes their own decision of whether or not to have children based on who they are, who their family is, who their community is, and the society that they live in. That a child possibly having depression should be a factor in these decisions, is up to each person making the choice. And if that person does decide to have a child after considering all of the factors, then that is no more or less responsible than any other parent.
So it is true that if you have a child, you must be prepared to support that child even as they struggle with a variety of challenges. And one of those might be a mental health condition. And it will be hard. Still, there are many parents who have children who face these challenges. So parents don’t need to go through it alone, and can seek out support from others who understand what they are going through. For example, on a site like this one. Parents who have suffered from depression may ultimately find their children will suffer from it as well. That’s not necessarily so terrible. Because those children when given love and care, may grow to be people whose perspective has a unique impact on the world at large.